walkiestime healthy debate is good yes, BUT.... telling someone they are a sad cow and to F off all the time is NOT on, I am not trying to cause an argument here as you say we all have our own opinions.
A mod will only be able to edit out the offensive language, or lock a thread, delete if really necessary, nothing else would be able to be done.
Go and read the thread from Friday night and you will know why we are all upset Thread by jmk called Try This
I find it quite disappointing that nothing (from what I have gathered) has been done by the YP team to have sorted the matter out.
I get the impression that there are no mods at all just James and his team, Sophie, Michael and isn't there another ? Anyways they are white collar workers Monday - Friday so weekends the forum can be a loose cannon as witnessed Friday night
One of the reasons why we definitely need a couple of moderators!
I certainly haven't, he never replies, leaves you feeling that you are not liked, and are a pain in the bum. Look how long it took to get the photo thread, and I have been asking for The Rainbow Bridge Poem to be made sticky on the Cat forum, like he did on the Dog forum. Waste of time, unless whats happened will make them sit up and finally take note I don't see there being any members being made mods in the foreseeable future, do you ?
It would definitely be ideal to have moderation 24/7 & have voted to that effect.
However , I think there are a practical issues associated with this. If you want 24/7 then there is a cost associated with it,
either in having enough international moderators such that all waking hours could be covered including holidays/sick for free
or in paying for people to do work shifts – costly for a free forum
Somehow I don’t think that wither of these options are going to happen so however this is done there will be no instantaneous moderation at all times.
Taking that in to consideration there would probably been no way what happened could have been stopped as it was late on a Friday evening/night only the removal of posts subsequently but that would be helpful.
This is a forum that is provided free of charge by a business (Bpgmedia) and as such must reflect their policies & procedures in the way it is managed . The thread that generated this poll I'm sure will not meet their criteria but if they appoint members as moderators who are not employed by the company then if there is any dispute about what those moderators have done then could there be business impact issues. This is something that they would have to be risk assessed.
Assuming that Bpgmedia do allow members to be moderators, with limited powers, what are those powers to be? I don’t know what is recorded in the forum logs if a post is deleted or edited but unless a before & after are done then there would be no record for subsequent review by the company only a record of who & when a specific action was taken. Having looked at the Proboards support forum one suggestion is to not delete but move to an archive only visible to admins etc. which presumable could be recovered after review.
There would have to be formal moderator procedures put in place regardless of what permissions are given.
The question of who would/could be moderators from the forum has to be one for Bpgmedia although it might be possible for some sort of recommendations to be given to them in the first place by the members.
As to word filters there are always ways around this we all know what s**t means is it any less bad language typed like that or bearing in mind the nature of this forum some words which could be treated as offence shouldn't be e.g. bitch. Such filters can be made on exact words or on containing the word think about Arsenal & Scunthorpe, which have been banned in early filters that used the containing option. However filters can be useful just used with care.
Having looked at the posts on this topic, there are some members who have concerns about forum members having moderator rights on the basis that they might abuse their powers. If the moderators were carefully chosen across all areas of the forum then I don’t think this would happen but I can understand their concerns.
I'm sorry if this sounds negative its not meant to be but to raise awareness of what this sort of decision could involve. If we want Bpgmedia to allow forum moderators over & above their staff/normal working hours we have to show we have considered the impact.
Happy days with Roman, Osiris & Lexie (remembering Chloe & Penny)
scallywag: just returned to our room having been on a roasting spit all day , pheww so HOT but a lovely cold pool is a step away
Mar 1, 2018 20:48:44 GMT
caz2golden: Glad you are having a fantastic holiday scallywag. Though you are missing some fantastic snow
Mar 2, 2018 21:46:47 GMT
caz2golden: 1 Tonib 1 Scallywag
Mar 2, 2018 21:48:07 GMT
scallywag: Ok so y days left in this glorious sunshine sooooo pleased I am missing all that white stuff, only white stuff here is the surf rolling over the white beaches hope its not forecast for end of next week
Mar 3, 2018 10:30:41 GMT
lotsofcats: Do you want us to keep you some snow?
Mar 3, 2018 19:34:53 GMT
alfiemummy: Our snow is already pretty much gone!
Mar 4, 2018 0:25:45 GMT
jassycat1: What spectacular weather you are having! Watching it on TV.
Mar 4, 2018 8:07:45 GMT
scallywag: No thanks no snow required Jenny
Mar 4, 2018 18:15:12 GMT
caz2golden: Get Well Scallywag
Mar 17, 2018 10:42:59 GMT
cazypops: Hope your feeling better soon Scallywag, Hugs.
Mar 18, 2018 0:30:10 GMT
scallywag: Thank you both, on the turn now so will be back up to full speed in no time at all xx
Mar 19, 2018 7:49:44 GMT